A 2013 AsapSCIENCE video depiction of the chicken and egg problem, which depicts the question: which came first the chicken or the egg? [3] |
“Moreover, I'll sing to the knowers' the sacred Oprhic discourse that not only makes the egg prior to the chicken but comprehensively attributes to it absolute priority over all things let the rest of that remain in science (as Herodotus says), because it is reserved for the initiate, but the fact remains that the world contains a vast range of living creatures, but every class of them participates in generation from an egg.”
“Since we know absolutely nothing about the relation of the atoms in living substance, would it not be a reasonable hypothesis to say that the nature of that marvelous process called metabolism is due to just the fact that the atoms of carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen, oxygen, etc., are undergoing perpetual change of valence? I see no reason why we may not legitimately imagine even consciousness due to such a process. Were such a hypothesis to be seriously taken, it would seem to follow that consciousness would have its roots wherever metabolism is going on. What an excellent starting point this would make for dealing with the perennial puzzle of how it is that the ‘mind influences the body’! The mind would then be part of the body.”
Hen + Rooster → New Chicken
AB + CD → AC + BD
H + H → H2
“Much of present-day biological knowledge is ideological. A key symptom of ideological thinking is the explanation that has no implications and cannot be tested. I call such logical dead ends antitheories because they have exactly the opposite effect of real theories: they stop thinking rather than stimulate it. Evolution by natural selection, for instance, which Charles Darwin originally conceived as a great theory, has lately come to function more as an antitheory, called upon to cover up embarrassing experimental shortcomings and legitimize findings that are at best questionable and at worst not even wrong. Your protein defies the laws of mass action? Evolution did it! Your complicated mess of chemical reactions turns into a chicken? Evolution! The human brain works on logical principles no computer can emulate? Evolution is the cause!”— Robert Laughlin (2005), A Different Universe (pgs. 168-69); cited (Ѻ) by William Dembski , 2005
“If you find an egg in your refrigerator, you're not surprised. You don't say, ‘Wow, that's a low-entropy configuration. That's unusual,’ because you know that the egg is not alone in the universe. It came out of a chicken, which is part of a farm, which is part of the biosphere, etc., etc. But with the universe, we don't have that appeal to make.”— Sean Carroll (c.2010) (Ѻ)