Overview In 1975, Rosnay, in his The Macroscope: a New World Scientific System, a mixture of cybernetics, systems theory, biochemistry, and thermodynamics, presented a human particle view, utilizing energy, entropy, negentropy, and free energy to a significant extent. [1] The following quote exemplifies Rosnay’s view:
All-in-all, Rosnay’s work is a readable mishmash of different theories, with an interesting global-view perspective, albeit laced with a very elementary understanding of thermodynamics.
In 1995, Rosnay, in his The Symbiotic Man, utilized discussions on entropy and life, citing the likes of Ilya Prigogine, Pierre Teilhard, and chaos theory, etc., and commenting, for instance, on how there are “two great tendencies of matter, toward life and toward entropy.” [2]
Difficulties on theory The central difficulties on Rosnay’s presentation are firstly that he mixes information theory concepts together with energy flow and thermodynamics, e.g. by citing French-born American physicist Leon Brillouin’s take on the situation, with no distinction. Secondly, in his application of entropy to society, similar in theme to Romanian mathematician Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen, he chalks off entropy to the part of fossil fuel that goes to waste in the flow-through of an economy (as depicted adjacent); whereas correctly, fossil fuel acts only as a catalyst on the activation energy of human chemical reactions. [3]
One of Rosnay's fossil fuel entropy diagrams
Third, Rosnay over-simplistically understands the concept of free energy in an economy. Although he defines free energy in a loose figurative sense (in a footnote) as “energy – entropy x absolute temperature”, he makes nonsensical statements such as “the increase in free energy at each stage in the transformation of a product during its manufacture is the physical equivalent of the economic concept of value added.”
As to evolution and entropy, Rosnay cites French soft-science philosopher’s Henri Bergson and Pierre Teilhard, concluding with them, it seems, that “life manifests itself as a current opposed to entropy.”