“You have made a convert of an opponent in one sense [of your Hereditary Genius], for I have always maintained that, excepting fools, men did not differ much in intellect, only in zeal and hard work.”Savant, as we see, is intellectually inept, in this regard.— Charles Darwin (c.1869), “Letter to Francis Galton” [16]
Example questions from the 1960 revised edition of the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale test, devised originally by Lewis Terman and Maud Merrill in 1937, that Savant took at age 11 (1947), scores from which, in 1985, she transformed “magically”, i.e. using number fudging methods, via the ratio IQ formula, into an IQ of 230. |
“Beyond age fifteen, the ‘mental ages’ are entirely artificial and are to be thought of as simply numerical scores.”— Lewis Terman (1937), Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale [2]
“Savant – the surname is real, it was her mother’s maiden name – has had a unique claim to fame since the mid-1980s. It was then, almost 30 years after she took a test as a schoolgirl in downtown St Louis, Missouri, that her IQ came to light. In 1985, Guinness World Records accepted that she had answered every question correctly on an adult Stanford-Binet IQ test at the age of just 10, a result that gave her a corresponding mental age of 22 years and 11 months, and an unearthly IQ of 228.”— Sam Knight (2009), “Is high IQ a burden as much as a blessing?”, Apr 10 [4]
“How do you know I’m the smartest women in the world? Nobody really knows that. Not that many people have taken an IQ test. I had the highest score on the Binet, so far. A very small minority of people in the world have taken test and what does Binet know, for heaven’s sake? I mean, back in 1904, he didn’t stumble over a Rosetta stone. He said: ‘this is what I’m going to do’ and everybody has been imitating him ever since.”
“Both the month that Marilyn took the test and the mental age she achieved on it are matters of some question that contribute to the murkiness over the Guinness top score. Her record with the St. Louis board of education shows she took the test in March 1957; she insists she first took it in September 1956. She says documents supporting her claims were provided by a teacher whose name she can’t remember and sent to Christopher Harding, a Mega society member, now in Australia.”— Julie Baumgold (1989), “In the Kingdom of the Brain” [1]
“Savant was given an old version of the Stanford-Binet (Terman & Merrill 1937), which did, indeed, use the antiquated formula of MA/CA × 100. But in the test manual's norms, the Binet does not permit IQs to rise above 170 at any age, child or adult. And the authors of the old Binet stated: 'Beyond fifteen the mental ages are entirely artificial and are to be thought of as simply numerical scores.' (Terman & Merrill 1937). The psychologist who came up with an IQ of 228 (see: IQ:225+) committed an extrapolation of a misconception, thereby violating almost every rule imaginable concerning the meaning of IQs.”— Alan Kaufman (2009), IQ Testing 101 [2]
“And what is it that makes Marilyn vos Savant so uniquely qualified to answer such questions? There is only one reason: she is listed in the Guinness Book of World Records as having the ‘highest IQ’ score ever recorded. Never mind that this record is based on a non-standardized test put out by an obscure group known as Mega, supposedly the world's most selective organization of geniuses. Ignore the fact that test scores at the extreme ends of any distribution are notoriously unreliable. Forget that vos Savant graduated 178th out of her class of 613 in high school, married young, failed to finish college, and by her own report reads very little. Her fame came, in the words of journalist Julie Baumgold [1989], ‘only because of the glory of that number.’ If vos Savant has ‘the highest IQ ever recorded’, surely she must be an expert on everything under the sun?’.”— Elaine Castles (2012), Inventing intelligence: How American Came to Worship IQ [3]
“Langan is an IQ charlatan like Jim Diamond, Marilyn Savant, Rick Rosner, etc.; people sell IQ nowadays like people used to sell snake oil in the old days.”— Libb Thims (2014), “Questions About IQ Ranges” (Ѻ), Hmolpedia forum, Dec 7
“I think Feynman, Wittgenstein, Austin, and Keynes should be on the list. They achieved so much more than an IQ-only phony like Marilyn vos Savant. I’m suspicious of those who only do stunts to show off memory and math. Let them invent a Microsoft or Apple like Gates or Jobs did, if they want to prove themselves to the world.”— Dexter Haven (2016), comment (Ѻ) on video “Smartest Person Ever | IQ:200 (4 of 4)”